More On Healing (Sort Of)
I wrote a piece earlier this year about my experience with Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS), a disorder that I had never heard of until I developed it. I have spent about seven years now trying to figure out what I have, then figuring out it was MCAS, and then dealing with the idea that it is poorly understood by a lot of medical professionals, despite it being an epidemic post-Covid. At the time I wrote the post, I was celebrating something that felt pretty miraculous: After years of debilitating joint pain, I had found a medication that made the pain go away. I was cautiously optimistic that I had finally figured out how to live comfortably in my body again.
For those unfamiliar with MCAS, mast cells are part of our immune system. They’re among the body’s first responders, releasing histamine and other chemical mediators when they perceive a threat. In people with MCAS, those cells can become activated inappropriately or excessively (unthinkable that my reactions to anything might be “normal.” As if.), producing symptoms that can affect multiple systems in the body. Skin flushing, gastrointestinal problems, racing heart, dizziness, brain fog, and sometimes anaphylaxis are all part of the mix. The triggers can be foods, medications, fragrances, temperature changes, stress, or apparently whatever the hell the mast cells have decided to object to that day. I usually describe the disorder as being “allergic to everything, but nothing consistently.”
Initially, the most debilitating symptom was joint pain, which began after radiation treatment for breast cancer. I suspect the radiation may have triggered or unmasked the condition, although I can’t prove that, and I spent years trying to figure out why my body seemed to be falling apart. Eventually, I was diagnosed with MCAS, and in September 2024, after reading some early research suggesting that GLP-1 medications might help with mast-cell-related symptoms, I started taking one.
The improvement was extraordinary. Over the following months, pain that had become a constant companion gradually disappeared, and I found myself able to do things that had become difficult or impossible. I still take the medication, and I still have essentially no pain. I remain profoundly grateful for that, particularly because the research is preliminary and GLP-1 medications are not established treatments for MCAS. (Here’s a study if you want to read why I tried them.)
So, the med calmed everything down, seemingly. Until it didn’t. Over the past several months, my reactions to foods, smells, and other environmental triggers have become increasingly unpredictable, and lately things have gotten pretty bad. Foods I’ve eaten without difficulty for years suddenly cause flushing, nausea, and tachycardia. Sugar, once a fairly reliable (if nutritionally empty) way to maintain my weight, has become problematic. In fact, the list of foods I can eat without worrying about a reaction seems to be getting shorter by the week.
Some nights, I feel like a flashing neon sign, with my face and body flushing and my heart racing, often after eating something that was perfectly fine the last time I ate it. The inconsistency is maddening because there doesn’t seem to be any reliable way to predict what will happen. I can eat something on Tuesday without incident and react to the same thing on Thursday. It’s difficult to plan meals when the rules keep changing, and it’s even more difficult to explain to people who understandably assume that if something makes you sick, you should simply stop eating it.
Recently, I’ve also had two reactions to perfume worn by clients (two different fragrances) that I had never encountered before. I’m a hugger, and hugging my clients has always felt natural to me, but on both occasions I had a significant systemic reaction to something as ordinary as being close to another person. Neither episode progressed to full-blown anaphylaxis, thankfully, but both were serious enough to scare me.
It’s a strange thing to become wary of something as simple as a hug.
I’ve spent some time reading the MCAS subreddit, where people describe experiences that make mine look easy. Some are down to a handful of foods they can tolerate, some require specialized nutritional support including feeding tubes, and others are struggling to get enough nourishment to sustain themselves. I don’t want to suggest that my experience is equivalent to theirs, because it isn’t, but there is something sobering about recognizing symptoms that sound familiar in people whose lives have become so profoundly restricted by this disease.
And this brings me to what may be the most frustrating part of the whole experience: trying to find medical care.
MCAS is a recognized condition, but the medical community is still sorting out how to diagnose it reliably, which symptoms and mechanisms belong under that umbrella, and how best to treat it. There are established diagnostic criteria, but testing can be complicated, particularly because the chemicals released by mast cells aren’t necessarily elevated at the moment someone happens to have blood drawn. There are also disagreements about how broadly the diagnosis should be applied. Some physicians have considerable expertise in mast cell disorders, while others have little familiarity with them, and some remain skeptical of the diagnosis altogether.
For patients, this can mean years of being bounced between specialists, each of whom may be looking at one piece of a much larger picture. A gastroenterologist sees the digestive symptoms, a cardiologist sees the racing heart, a dermatologist sees the flushing, and nobody necessarily puts the pieces together. I saw a whole host of rheumatologists and neurologists and nutritionists. It was a lot.
I was fortunate enough to find a wonderful physician who understood the condition and was willing to help me navigate it. She was knowledgeable, compassionate, curious, and genuinely interested in figuring out what was happening in my body, which is exactly what you want from a physician when you’re dealing with something that doesn’t fit neatly into the usual diagnostic categories.
Then she joined a new concierge practice.
I want to be very clear that I don’t fault her for this decision. I know enough about the business of Western medicine to understand why physicians are leaving traditional practices in search of a model that allows them to spend more time with patients and practice medicine in a way that feels consistent with their values, and still make a living. Our insurance-driven healthcare system has made it increasingly difficult for doctors to provide the kind of individualized, thoughtful care that complex conditions require, and I don’t begrudge anyone trying to find a sustainable way to do good work. I face similar challenges as a therapist in private practice.
But the cost of joining her new practice was $4,000, and at the time I was buying a house, so I made the decision not to spend that money. I figured I could get back in when things settled down.
Her waitlist is now two years long.
I’ve tried other physicians, with disappointing results, and so here I am, dealing with a condition that has become considerably more disruptive while struggling to find someone with the expertise and willingness to help me manage it.
I understand that clinicians cannot be experts in everything. I also understand how difficult it is to work within a system that rewards efficiency and volume, particularly when the patients who need the most help are often the ones whose problems require time, research, collaboration, and a willingness to tolerate uncertainty. Insurance companies, which I have long regarded as a form of legal organized crime, have managed to insert themselves between patients and providers in ways that make this kind of care increasingly difficult to deliver.
I do have a fair amount going for me in this situation. I’m educated, I have financial resources, I’m comfortable reading medical research, and I’m accustomed to advocating for myself. I have a professional understanding of how healthcare systems work, and I’m not easily intimidated by medical professionals. If I’m having this much trouble finding appropriate care, it is troubling to think about people who don’t have those advantages, particularly those whose symptoms are so severe that they barely have the energy to get through the day, much less navigate the labyrinth of referrals, insurance requirements, and specialists who may or may not be able to help.
I also think about the physicians who genuinely want to provide this kind of care and are finding it increasingly difficult to do so. My former doctor didn’t stop caring about her patients when she joined a concierge practice. She found a way to continue doing the work she loves without being ground down by a system that makes that work unnecessarily difficult. Unfortunately, the solution that makes her practice sustainable also makes her care inaccessible to a lot of people who need it.
I’m not sure what the answer is, but I’m pretty sure the current arrangement isn’t it.
Meanwhile, I’m still trying to figure out what I can eat, what might be setting off these reactions, and how to get my body to settle down again. I continue to be grateful for the absence of pain, because I remember all too well what it was like to wake up every morning already hurting and know that I would be hurting when I went to bed. That part of my life has changed dramatically, and I don’t want to lose sight of it just because something else has become difficult.
But I also find myself increasingly frustrated by how much attention this condition demands. I don’t particularly want to think about a possible reaction every time I eat something, or wonder whether someone’s perfume is going to make me sick, or spend my evenings trying to figure out why my heart is racing when all I’ve done is drink some water. I have a full life, a practice I love, people I adore, and approximately a thousand things I’d rather be thinking about.
I want to believe this is a particularly bad season and that things will settle down again, as they have before. In the meantime, I’m trying to find better medical support, keep myself nourished, and remember that the body that is currently driving me absolutely nuts is the same body that has carried me through most of my life with joy.
“Our body is a masterpiece of the cosmos. Our body carries within it the stars, the moon, the universe, and the presence of all our ancestors. How many millions of years of evolution has it taken to give rise to these wondrous two eyes, legs, feet, and hands? Countless life-forms are supporting our existence in this moment. Reconnecting with our physical body takes only a few moments of stopping and breathing with awareness.
—Thich Nhat Hanh

Comments